Dr. Miklos K. Radvanyi
The list of public figures, scholars of history, and other excitable private individuals who level the accusations that Jews took Arab land is infinite. One of the last so-called experts who has shared his historical, legal, and political opinions about this subject is the former U.S. President Barack Hussein Obama. His recent remarks in Belfast, Northern Ireland, raise questions that extend far beyond the never-ending conflict in the Middle East. They concern the historical legitimacy of Jewish sovereignty, the distinction between national self-determination as well as territorial dispossession, and the responsibilities of political leaders when analyzing the world’s most complicated conflicts.
Speaking in Belfast on October 13, 2026, Barack Hussein Obama who was registered under his stepfather’s name as Barry Soetero and whose religion was shown in the Indonesian school registry as Muslim, raised substantial historical issues that compressed several distinct historical processes into an extremely one-sided narrative, in which Jews sought refuge in someone else’s land and displaced its inhabitants. Clearly, his narrative is typical Obamaian. With a barely average intellect and a huge amount of religion-based personal bias, his narrative does not objectively explain the Jewish people’s indigenous historical connections, the legal foundations of Zionist settlement, or the circumstances surrounding the State of Israel’s establishment. In his superficially philistine presentation, the former president acknowledged the undeniable persecution of the Jews in Europe and their search for refuge in a territory to which they had historical ties. He then stated: “What is also undeniable is that they took the land of people and they were expelled.” He added that those displaced understandably regarded the experience as an injustice and wanted their land returned. The distinction is important. Barack Hussein Obama did not literally use the word stealing in the reported passage. Nevertheless, his characterization of land being taken and people expelled carries an unmistakable accusation of dispossession. He also argued falsely that the State of Israel’s military superiority does not relieve it of moral obligations toward the Arabs he falsely called Palestinians. Thus, his statement should not be interpreted as an explicit denial of the State of Israel’s right to exist. The more consequential question is whether his historical explanation accurately identifies how the State of Israel came into existence not just in 1948, but also in a historical perspective.
The first historical dereliction of his deficient presentation is that Jewish history did not begin with European persecution. The Holocaust undoubtedly accelerated international support for Jewish statehood. Yet, Zionism preceded the Holocaust by centuries, and Jewish identification with the Land of Israel also preceded modern Zionism by millennia. The arc of history of Jewish struggle for national independence started with the Tanach and materialized in 1948. Essentially, Jewish history has been a permanent struggle to preserve religious identity, national existence, and political independence in the face of foreign domination. Viewed through the intellectual framework of Zionism, this history is not simply a succession of persecutions, expulsions, and tragedies. It is also a history of resistance, national survival, political restoration, and the persistent aspiration to return to sovereign existence in the ancestral homeland. Thus, Jewish history contains a recurring tension between political independence and the realities of survival under foreign power.
The founding narrative of Jewish liberation is the Exodus from Egypt. According to the biblical narrative, the Israelites were subjected to Egyptian bondage before Moses led them toward freedom and the Promised Land. The importance of the Exodus lies in three interconnected ideas: liberation from foreign subjugation, the establishment of a people bound together by law and covenant, and the connection between national identity and a particular territory. From a Zionist perspective, the Exodus provides a powerful historical model: a dispersed or subjugated people can become a self-governing nation. During the period traditionally associated with the Judges and the early monarchy, biblical accounts describe conflicts with the Philistines, Moabites, Midianites, and other neighboring peoples. The stories of Samson, Saul, David became enduring symbols of resistance and political consolidation. The emergence of the kingdoms of Israel and Judah established an important historical precedent: Jewish national existence was not understood solely as a religious community, but also as a territorial government.
During the eighth and seventh centuries, the Israelites fought the expanding Assyrian Empire. Although the Assyrian King Sennacherib invaded Judah in 701 BCE, Jerusalem survived. In the sixth century, King Jehoiakim rebelled against Babylonian authority. Later, King Zedekiah rebelled against Nebuchadnezzar II in 597 BCE. The Babylonian response was devastating. In 587/586 BCE, Jerusalem fell, the First Temple was destroyed, and significant portions of the Judean population were deported. This catastrophe transformed Jewish history. Yet, the destruction of the monarchy did not destroy Jewish identity. Instead, Jewish religious institutions, historical memory, and attachment to Jerusalem became essential instruments of collective survival. The Babylonian exile established a recurring principle in Jewish national consciousness: the loss of sovereignty did not necessarily extinguish the idea of nationhood. The return of Judean exiles under Persian rule, beginning after Cyrus’s conquest of Babylon in 539 BCE, subsequently became an important precedent for restoration. Yet, the Second Temple community did not recover the full independence of the earlier monarchy. It developed initially under Persian imperial authority. This distinction between return to the homeland and genuine political sovereignty would become central to later Zionist thinking.
The Maccabean Revolt between 167 and 142 BCE, occupies an especially important position in the historical interpretation of Zionism. After Alexander the Great’s conquests, Judea came under Hellenistic domination, eventually becoming a part of the Seleucid Empire. King Antiochus IV Epiphanes attempted to impose religious restrictions upon the Jews, interfering with Temple worship and prohibiting important Jewish practices. In 167 BCE, Matathias, a Jewish priest, initiated an uprising led by his son Judas Maccabeus. The uprising combined religious resistance with the pursuit of national political autonomy. Its achievements included the recovery and rededication of the Jerusalem Temple in 164 BCE, commemorated by Hanukkah, and the eventual establishment of an independent Hasmonean state around 142 BCE. The uprising evolved from defending religious practices into establishing military and political sovereignty. The Maccabees demonstrated that Jewish independence could be restored after prolonged foreign domination. Three of these lessons became particularly important to Zionist historical interpretation. First, national liberation required organized political leadership. Second, armed resistance could succeed when imperial authority weakened. Third, political independence could not necessarily be maintained without domestic unity. In 63 BCE, Pompey entered Jerusalem, ending effective Jewish independence.
The subsequent Roman domination again generated growing tensions over taxation, political authority, religious practices, and the conduct of imperial officials. Jewish society itself was divided among competing religious and political movements. The Zealots and other militant groups advocated resistance. Other Jewish leaders believed rebellion against Rome would produce national catastrophe. In 66 CE, the uprising escalated into a general war. Jewish insurgents initially achieved military successes, including a significant victory over Roman forces under Cestius Gallus. Rome responded with overwhelming military force. Vespasian began the campaign, and his son Titus ultimately besieged Jerusalem. In 70 CE, Roman forces captured the city and destroyed the Second Temple. The remaining resistance was suppressed, with Masada falling in 73 CE. This revolt revealed a fundamental contradiction. Jewish rebels sought independence from Rome, yet competing Jewish factions fought among themselves even while confronting the Roman army. The destruction of Jerusalem transformed Jewish religious and political life for centuries. Masada became a powerful symbol of Jewish resistance. In modern Jewish memory, the defenders represented determination not to submit to foreign domination.
A frequently neglected chapter concerns Jewish uprisings during the reign of Emperor Trajan. Uprisings occurred in Cyrene, Cyprus, and parts of Mesopotamia. Unlike the Maccabean Uprising, these uprisings were not exclusively territorial struggles for independence in Judea. They involved conflicts between Jewish and non-Jewish populations, tensions with Roman authority, and expectations of religious as well as political transformation. The fighting was exceptionally destructive. Roman suppression devastated several established Jewish communities, particularly in Egypt and Cyrenaica. The precise motivations remain disputed , and the conflicts included violence against civilians as well as religious sites. From a Zionist historical perspective, these events are significant because they demonstrate that Jewish political and religious grievances were not confined to Jerusalem.
The Bar Kochba Revolt of 132-135 CE was the last great attempt at Jewish independence. Moreover, the Revolt led by Simon Bar Kochba represents perhaps the clearest ancient parallel to modern Zionist aspirations. The background of the Revolt was Emperor Hadrian’s dominating policies against the Jewish people. Plans to establish a Roman colony, Aelia Capitolina, at Jerusalem were particularly inflammatory. Restrictions concerning circumcision may also have contributed to the burgeoning anti-Roman sentiments. As a result, Bar Kochba organized a major Rebellion in 132 CE. His forces established control over substantial parts of Judea and created an administration that issued documents and coins. Some coins even proclaimed the freedom or redemption of Israel and Jerusalem. The movement, therefore, represented an explicit attempt at the restoration of Jewish political independence. Rabbi Akiva’s association with Bar Kochba also contributed to the Rebellion’s messianic significance. By 135 CE, the Rebellion had been defeated. Large areas of Judea were devastated and many inhabitants were killed, enslaved, or displaced. From a Zionist standpoint, Bar Kochba became a symbol of both national courage and the immense dangers of an unsuccessful revolt.
Yet, the Bar Kochba defeat did not end Jewish armed resistance. Several subsequent episodes deserve attention. Between 361 and 352 CE, Jewish communities in Roman Palestine rebelled during the reign of Constantius II, when Gallus governed the eastern provinces. During the Byzantine-Sasanian War, some Jewish groups supported the Persian invasion of Byzantine Palestine. The Persian capture of Jerusalem in 614 involved Jewish participation. Jewish resistance during the early Islamic centuries did periodically emerge, including the ninth-century movement associated with Abu Isa al-Isfahani, whose chronology and historical details are uncertain. Jewish communities in medieval Christian Europe generally did not possess sovereign territorial governments or standing armies. During the Crusades, particularly in 1096, Jewish communities in the Rhineland confronted massacres, forced conversion, and destruction. Some resisted violently. Others chose martyrdom rather than conversion. Jewish resistance also occurred in later episodes of persecution, but the overwhelming disparity in m military power usually made organized revolt impossible. The Zionist interpretation of this history emphasizes the vulnerability of communities without sovereign protection. Yet, Jewish survival in medieval Europe also depended upon sophisticated communal institutions, religious scholarship, legal negotiations, and transregional solidarity. Thus, political powerlessness did not mean historical passivity.
The emergence of modern political Zionism in the nineteenth-century represented a fundamental transformation. Earlier generations preserved hopes for restoration through religious tradition, prayer, migration, and occasional messianic movements. Modern Zionists sought to convert those aspirations into a practical political program. The nineteenth-century rise of European nationalism, together with antisemitic persecution and the limitations of Jewish emancipation, provided the immediate political context.Theodor Herzl argued that Jewish security could not depend entirely upon the tolerance of other governments. The First Zionist Congress met in Basel, Switzerland, in 1897. Its program sought a publicly and legally secured homeland for the Jewish people in the ancient Israel-Judea-Samaria. The distinctive feature of modern Zionism was not the invention of Jewish attachment to Zion. That attachment existed for centuries. The transformation was the effort to make Jewish national restoration an achievable objective through immigration, settlement, diplomacy, institution-building, and eventually military organization. The historical memory of the Maccabees and Bar Kochba became part of this modern political vocabulary.
Following antisemitic violence in the Russian Empire in the early twentieth-century, Jewish self-defense organizations emerged in several communities. Their significance was both practical and ideological. They challenged the assumption that Jews should respond to violence exclusively through appeals to state authorities or communal endurance. The Warsaw Ghetto Uprising of April-May 1943 became one of the most significant episodes of Jewish armed resistance during the Holocaust. Jewish fighters confronted German forces despite extraordinary shortages of weapons, ammunition, and supplies. Other revolts occurred in ghettos and extermination camps, including Treblinka as well as Sobibor. Jewish partisan groups also operated in German-occupied Europe.
Following the First World War, Great Britain governed what was then called Palestine under a League of Nations Mandate. Jewish political movements differed over how to achieve statehood. The Haganah developed as a major Jewish defense organization. The Irgun and Lehi pursued more militant campaigns, including attacks against British authorities. During the 1940s, Jewish underground organizations engaged in armed resistance against British restrictions and policies. Their methods were controversial, including attacks that killed civilians. The establishment of the State of Israel in 1948 resulted from multiple interacting developments: Zionist institution-building, British withdrawal, international diplomacy, the Holocaust’s aftermath, the UN partition proposal, and war. However, it cannot be attributed exclusively to armed revolt.
In conclusion, five major verdicts can be surmised from a Zionist historical perspective. First, Jewish national identity survived the destruction of Jewish sovereignty. Second, the relationship between religious freedom and national independence was central to Jewish identity. Third, Rebellion and survival were competing imperatives. Fourth, Jewish independence was repeatedly affected by internal divisions. Fifth, modern Zionism changed the means of pursuing restoration.
A final historical reflection reveals the striking contrast between the Jewish revolts of antiquity and the Zionist movement of modern times. The Maccabees fought an established empire and ultimately achieved independence. The rebels of 66 CE fought Rome and suffered catastrophic defeat. Bar Kochba temporarily restored Jewish political authority, but could not withstand Rome’s military response. Modern Zionism arose under very different international circumstances and pursued sovereignty through a combination of political organization, diplomacy, settlement, and armed struggle. The idea that Jewish collective existence could include political self-government in the historic homeland has been triumphant. The central Zionist interpretation of Jewish history is thus not simply that Jews repeatedly rebelled. It is that the memory of independence survived repeated defeats and at the end became the foundation of a modern national movement.
As long as Barack Hussein Obama and all the other ideologically biased haters do not comprehend that how the Maccabean and Bar Kochba traditions influenced Theodor Herzl, Vladimir Jabotinsky, David Ben-Gurion, and the development of the State of Israel’s national-security doctrine, they will remain the incorrigible geopolitical dimwits of history.