Dr. Miklos K. Radvanyi
Very recently, the President of the People’s Republic of China reiterated his and his country’s support for the Palestinian people, urging the international community to take action to end the suffering in Gaza and uphold international law. More specifically, he called upon every state to distance itself from the State of Israel over the “Genocide” in Gaza.
Putting aside the facts that archeologists have proven that Arabs are not indigenous to Israel-Judea-Samaria, that there is no state of Palestine, there are no Arab “Palestinians,” and there have never been any Arab “Palestinians,” President Xi Jinping’s debilitating Chinese linguistic malfeasance, compounded by his amateurish uttering of the extremely loosely used word “genocide,” it would be very educational to carefully examine Chinese history in light of his irresponsible statements.
In Chinese history, the word “genocide,” known also as ethnic extermination, is retrospective because the legal term was only created in 1948. The first event in Chinese history that resulted in the extermination of the Wu Hu, especially the Jie, was carried out between 350-351 AD during the Sixteen Kingdom’s period upon the order of the founder of the Ran Wei, the Han leader Ran Min. Ancient Chinese text records that General Ran Min ordered the extermination of the Wu Hu, especially the Jie people, during the Wei-Jie war in the fourth century AD. According to traditional Chinese sources, at least 200,000 Jie were ruthlessly murdered. As a consequence, the Jie as an identifiable group totally disappeared.
Taking a great leap to the 18th century, the Dzungar Genocide between 1755-1758, during the Qing Dynasty is the next Chinese extermination of an ethnic group. As its name indicates, the Dzungar genocide was the mass extermination of the Dzungar people. The Qianlong Emperor of the Qing Dynasty ordered the genocide after the rebellion in 1755. According to the Qing Dynasty scholar Wei Yuan, 40% of the 600,000 Dzungars were killed by smallpox, 20% fled…and 30% were killed by the Qing army. The order demanded the murder of all the men in Barkol or Sunzhou with the additional demand of dividing the wives and children among the Qing forces. Historian Peter Perdue has argued that decimation was the result of an explicit policy of genocide, and Michael Edmund Clarke described it as “the complete destruction of not only the Zunghar state but of the Zunghars as a people.” Estimates, based upon ancient documents claim put the Dzunghar pre-genocide population at between 600,000 in 200,000 households. Out of this number, 70-80%, approximately 480,000 to 600,000 were murdered and forced to flee. In brief, the Qing Dynasty’s army also slaughtered 80% of the Oirat Mongols. Afterward, the Qing Dynasty resettled the depopulated Dzungaria, with Uyghur, Han, Hui, and Manchu settlers.
Other mass exterminations that are not always legally labeled as genocide are the Ming-Qing transition massacres in the 17th century and the Qing suppression of Muslim uprisings in the 18th and 19th centuires. The first massacre occurred in 1645, also known as the Yangzhu Ten Days, after the Manchu conquest. The Qing army under Dodo killed an estimated several hundred thousand civilians in Yangzhu after resistance. Another genocide was the Zhang Xiazhing Massacre in Sichuan between 1644 and 1646. The rebel leader who took Sichuan is said to have ordered the systematic slaughter of the entire population, leading to almost total depopulation. Numbers are contested, but Ming loyalist sources claim hundreds of thousands to several millions.
The second was the Qing suppression of the Muslim uprising in the 18th and 19th centuries, starting with the Qianlong’s suppression of the Jahriyya revolt between 1781 and 1784. This was followed by the Panthay Rebellion between 1856 and 1873, in Yunnan and the Dungan Revolt between 1862 and 1977, in Shaanxi, Gansu, and Xinjiang. Both sides engaged in communal extermination. Qing general Zuo Zongtang’s reconquest involved mass killings of Hui communities, with over a million deaths in total.
The period between the 1911 Revolution and the establishment of the People’s Republic of China on October 1, 1949, is not characterized by a single state-run extermination program like the Holocaust, but it contains several episodes of mass killing. The violence came from three different sources: internal political purges, warlord-civil war fighting, and Japanese occupation. Within this period, the years between 1911 and 1928 were the years of Revolution and Warlord Era. The Revolution itself and the early Republic were violent, but not exterminatory. After Yuan Shikai’s death in 1916, China fragmented under warlords. Warfare was chronic, with press-ganging, banditry, and reprisal massacres of villages suspected of supporting a rival warlord. Death tolls were very high in aggregate, but decentralized, not a state organized policy to annihilate an ethnic group. The years between 1927 and 1937 are known as the time of White Terror and Red Terror. This was the first period with systematic mass killings. After Chiang Kai-shek broke with the Communists in April 1927, the Shanghai Massacre and subsequent nationwide purges targeted Communists, labor unionists, and suspected leftist in general. Historians estimate hundreds of thousands killed in 1927-1928 alone, and millions over the next decade in KMT suppression campaigns. The encirclement campaigns against the Jiangxi Soviet included collective punishment of villages. Consequently, the CCP mounted its own counter-violence. Inside CCP-controlled territories, particularly during the Futian incident between 1930 and 1931, and other anti-counterrevolutionary campaigns in the Jiangxi Soviet, the CCP carried out its own purges, executing hundreds of thousands of suspected KMT spies and dissenting party members.
The final civil war was brutal, but again primarily military and political, not ethnic. Both KMT and CCP engaged in execution of prisoners of war, retaliatory massacres against villages supporting the other side, and land-reform killings in CCP-liberated areas.
The Mao era between 1949 and 1976 is studied as a case of mass state-induced extermination rather than legal genocide. Under the 1948 United Nations Genocide Convention, genocide requires provable intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnic, racial or religious group. Mao’s campaign targeted political and social categories – landlords, so-called counterrevolutionaries, rightists, capitalist roaders – which are not protected groups under that definition. Because of that, most legal scholars and historians classify the era as democide, not genocide in the strictly legal sense, with one major exception: Tibet.
Tibet under Mao is the one case where “genocide” was formally investigated under international law. Tibet had been de facto independent after the Qing Dynasty’s collapse. In 1950, the People’s Liberation Army (PLA) captured Chamdo in eastern Tibet, then forced negotiations in Beijing. The 1951 Seventeen Point Agreement gave Tibet autonomy on paper, while recognizing Chinese sovereignty. The then-Dalai Lama later repudiated it as coercive after fleeing to India in 1959. Early on, Mao told the Dalai Lama in 1954 that the People’s Republic of China would move farmers to Tibet. “Sinicization” began in Kham and Amdo. In traditional Chinese tyrannical fashion, the old social structure was destroyed, leaders arrested or summarily executed, and most of the monasteries were closed. That triggered guerilla revolts in Kham and Amdo from 1956 onward. Later, official Chinese statements acknowledged that almost all monasteries were destroyed not just in Mao’s other inhuman campaign called the “Cultural Revolution,” but during the “democratic reforms” after the 1959 uprising. Then in 1959 came the Lasha Uprising. The whole plateau erupted in 1959 and was crushed by the PLA. Around 2,000 PLA soldiers were killed in the uprising, and in the immediate aftermath. According to a secret PLA document, which was purportedly captured by Tibetan guerillas, only in Lhasha 87,000 deaths were recorded between March 1959 and September 1960. The same PLA report is quoted as saying that between March 1959 and September 1960, 87,000 Tibetans were “exterminated” in Central Tibet alone. Chinese demographer Yan Hao has questioned the document provenance – noting that it was captured in 1966, and only published in 1990 by an exile organization. To make these claims even more credible, exiled sources put the number of “exterminated” Tibetans even much higher: “The destruction…was brutal during the twenty years following the uprising. 1.2 million Tibetans, one-fifth of the country’s population, died as a result of the People Republic of China’s policies…and more than 6000 monasteries, temples and other cultural and historic buildings were destroyed.” Moreover, “The invasion triggered cultural suppression, with monetaries destroyed and over 1.2 million Tibetan deaths reported by 1979 due to the conflict and policies.” Furthermore, the Great Leap Forward, another idiocy of Mao’s sick mind, applied to Tibet as well. Nomads were forced to settle, barley (tsampa) was replaced by wheat and maize unsuited to altitude, and famines appeared for the first time in recorded history. Finally, the Cultural Revolution of the 1960s finished the total obliteration of Tibetan the barely remaining monasteries and temples. As a result, even private religious observance became illegal.
In 1959-1960, the International Commission of Jurists, after examining evidence in Geneva, Switzerland, found that: “the People’s Republic of China’s treatment of Tibetans constituted genocide.” It cited: the killing of Tibetans as a group, the causing serious bodily and mental harm, the deliberate inflicting conditions calculated to destroy the group, and the forcible transfer of children. Moreover, three UN General Assembly resolutions in 1959, in 1961, and in 1965, condemned violations, with one UN report saying: “The Chinese occupation of Tibet has been characterized by acts of murder, rape, and arbitrary imprisonment; torture and cruel, inhuman and degraded treatment of Tibetans on a large scale.” Even Chinese scholars who reject physical genocide agree on cultural destruction. That is why the term “cultural genocide” is now commonly accepted and used.
The treatment of the Muslims in China deserves another unbiased examination. Muslims have been in China since the 7th century. Their collective experience throughout the centuries with mass killing also reinforced the Nazi-like mentality of the Han-Chinese. In this respect, there are three periods where historians use the word “genocide.” First, the Qing suppression in the 19th century. During the mid-nineteenth century, Muslims and the Miao people of China revolted against the Qing Dynasty, most notably in the Dungan Revolt between 1962 and 1877and the Panthay Rebellion between 1856 and 1873 in Yunnan. These little known revolts were brutally suppressed by the Manchu government in a manner that amounts to “genocide.” Several Qing Dynasty officials remembered these two revolts as military campaigns that “washed off the Muslims.” After 2014, the situation did not improve. In Xinjiang province up to 1-3 million Uyghurs and other Turkic Muslims – Kazakhs, Kyrgyz – were detained in what China calls “Vocational Education and Training Centers.” In these cruel prisons, forced sterilization, forced labor, mass surveillance, restrictions on Islam, and separation of children are routine daily occurrences. On that basis, on January 19, 2021, then- Secretary of State Mike Pompeo issued a determination that the mass atrocities against Muslim Uyghurs and other members of ethnic and religious minority groups in Xinjiang constitutes genocide, and crimes against humanity. The U.S. Senate concurred by declaring the atrocities perpetrated by the government of the People’s Republic of China against Uyghurs, ethnic Kazakhs, Kyrgyz, and members of other Muslim minority groups in the Xinjiang Uyghur Autonomous Region constitute genocide. Furthermore, Canada’s House of Commons voted 266-0 in 2021 to recognize it as a genocide. The UK, Netherlands, and others have passed similar non-binding motions. To no one’s surprise, Beijing denies everything.
In light of this abysmal Chinese history, President Xi’s Gaza rhetoric serves only a single strategic purpose: it presents Beijing as a defender of international justice, while placing the State of Israel – and, indirectly, the United States of America – on the defensive. Moreover, his language pursues three interconnected objectives: strengthening Beijing’s appeal to Arab governments and audiences, challenging American claims to uphold a consistent international order, and promoting Beijing as an alternative center of constructive diplomatic authority. Yet, there is a central strategic weakness in President Xi’s one-sided as well as distorted presentation of the Middle East conundrum. President Xi claims authority as a guardian of international justice, while applying scrutiny unevenly by leaving essential security obligations barely addressed. Therefore, any Chinese accusation should be tested by a straightforward question: What evidence establishes the required intent, and how does President Xi’s unfounded accusations address competing explanations and contrary evidence?
More importantly, President Xi does not understand that the Middle East conundrum has not been born of a conflict of competing geopolitical interests among the great powers. On the contrary, it has been born of the intellectual, moral, and political chaos of World War I as well as World War II. Along with the wholesale destruction of the Ottoman Empire, the Middle East was crowded with the League of Nations’s incompetent mandate system that was badly mismanaged by Great Britain and France, and the avalanche of illegitimate governments that lived in permanent fear of their own people. Out of this chaos has grown instability and weakness that destroyed all the elements of legitimacy. Consequently, the thus established counterfeit governments were left like a pilot without a compass. From there on, no fixed point had to be found in a horribly changing world. No wonder that these regional governments have been so ill-prepared for the task of governance. Since these times, extremely confused and unhappy generations have been destroying even the minimal order in the region, in the belief that they are saving it from total annihilation. The thus ensuing terrorism has devastated the Middle East throughout the greater part of the 20th and the first two-and-a-half decades of the 21st centuries.
These vicious circles of ubiquitous fear and violence have not been broken at all. The reason has been that both inside the Middle East and across the globe mostly insignificant men – and occasionally women – have failed to make great decisions. Sadly, President Xi belongs to this group of politicians who were unqualified to comprehend that the Middle East produced a uniquely contradictory situation, in which the dual force of ossified conditions has been in permanent conflict with the principles of liberal democracy. The real victims of this conundrum are the Arab masses who will continue to exist under the thumb of tyrannical misery that thus far no one has been able to eliminate.
